(The following is my actual game play experience)
AHHHHHHHHH!! Oh my god... what is that?!
Where the hell did that come from?!
Fucking flashlight... turn on... not now... AH FUCK!
AH GOD KILL IT! *BLAM BLAM* oh god... it's just a corpse they threw at me. *pant pant* *thump-thump*
*HUD flickers* what was that?!
FUCK! Get out of my head!
*Looks over shoulder in RL, looking for the girl in the red dress*
*Power fluctuates in game* *power fluctuates in real life making the lights flicker and the tv to snap and the cable box to reboot.
Ok... that was...
*thing falls off the shelf in game* *thing falls off the shelf in real life*
@.o
fuuuuck....!
*turns the game off*
(end game excerpt)
Ok... synopsis:
As you can all see, this game frightens me. It's not right that real life imitates such a game. I lost sleep that night.
But this is a suspensful game. I haven't played most resident evil games except for 4, but imagine that part in RE 1 where the dogs jump out at you through the window from the outside. Yeah... imagine that happening constantly through the whole game.
I haven't dared play Silent hill, but I hear that one will make you wet your pants too.
Not only do you have lotsa bad guys (a brigade) but you have some psychotic psychics to contend with... namely the girl in a red dress, and the commander for the soldiers.
Suspence is everywhere...
My favorite is this part:
In games like half life and others whenever you approach a ladder, you bend over turn around with your head down, and then you look up before descending the ladder. Well right when you look up... there's the fucking girl!
*screams like a little girl*
Ok... I'm a pansy. I admit it. This game frightens me. For you he-men and she-women, who like suspense, you may just shrug at this and think I'm a wuss... well... you're right.
I cannot give this an overall game play cause I can't stop focusing on the insanity.
As for suspensful insanity... I give this game a 6 out of 5. Yes... more than five
Masterful sound and lighting (even your HUD flickers with that tweaker light effect that keeps you lookin over your shoulder looking for the guy whose about to shiv ya... I mean looking over your shoulder in real life) The best way of playing this game for greatest level of suspense is with the lights off, a big screen, and isolate the sound with a pair of headphones... so that when that ghost whispers in your ear... you get the full effect

"She hates you"
"I was cut from her, I am a part of you."
"I'm going to kill you..."